Tuesday, November 25, 2025

"The Revolution in New England Justified, and the People there Vindicated" - 1688 & 1776 again


Another superb source! Following the Boston Revolt of April 1689 (when, following the arrival of copies of William Prince of Orange's Declaration, colonists rose up to overthrow the colonial government of King James II and his Governor Edmund Andros) two accounts of the Revolt were published.

• The first was by lawyer John Palmer (bio here) who had been one of those seized and imprisoned by the 'rebels'. While imprisoned, he wrote his An Impartial Account of the State of New England, or the late Government there vindicated - it circulated in manuscript form and was printed in London in 1690 (online here).

• The second account, a response/rebuttal of Palmer entitled The Revolution in New England Justified, and the People there Vindicated was written in 1691 by Edward Rawson (Wikipedia here) and Samuel Sewall (Wikipedia here). Their preface explained what a liberty-oriented 'limited monarchy' was:

"but there are a sort of men, who call those that are for English liberties, and that rejoice in the government of their majesties, king William and queen Mary, by the name of republicans, and represent all such as enemies of monarchy and of the church. It is not our single opinion only, but we can speak it on the behalf of the generality of their majesties subjects in New-England; that they believe (without any diminution to the glory of our former princes) the English nation was never so happy in a king, or in a queen, as at this day. And the God of heaven, who has set them on the throne of these kingdoms, grant them long and prosperously to reign"

and the introduction:

"THE doctrine of passive obedience and non-resistance, which a sort of men did of late, when they thought the world would never change, cry up as divine truth, is by means of the happy revolution in these nations, exploded, and the assertors of it become ridiculous." 

It included an appendix entitled A Narrative of the Proceedings of Sir Edmund Androsse and his Accomplices who acted by an Illegal and Arbitrary Commission from the late King James, during his Government in New England - written by five gentlemen who had served under Andros (Wikipedia here). But few revolutions are truly complete, and Andros was made Governor of Virginia by William III and Mary II.

.....................

• Nearly a century later with a new revolution in the air, in April 1773 the 24 year old Boston printer, and member of the Sons of Liberty movement, Isaiah Thomas (Wikipedia here) dusted down the Rawson and Sewell book and reprinted it, to remind the city's readership that there had been a justified revolution before. The Sons of Liberty would occasionally hold meetings in his print shop, and perhaps they imbibed the contents of 1689. Thomas advertised his reprint in the 8 April 1773 edition of his seditious newspaper The Massachussetts Spy or Thomas's Boston Journal.

And just eight months later, tea was floating in Boston Harbour....

• The 1773 Thomas edition is on Archive.org here

• Text is online here





Tuesday, November 11, 2025

"the three strands of political thought that shaped America’s founding - Lockean liberalism, classic republicanism, and Protestant Christianity"

This 2022 article by Kevin DeYoung on World News Group is worth a read...

The founders' emphasis on liberty was not a rejection of Christianity but based on Christian ideas about the sanctity of the conscience and the corruptibility of too much power in the hands of too few persons.

Wednesday, November 05, 2025

Professor David Armitage on the 1688 & 1776 connections - "move beyond nationalist paradigms"

I saw this Zoom broadcast, hosted by the National Army Museum in London, back in April of this year. Professor David Armitage (Harvard webpage here) makes a number of critical points here. I've lifted these from the YouTube transcript, but do listen to the whole for proper context.

..........................

From 3:00 –

"... it's very useful indeed and very important historically to reconsider the war of independence as a Civil War and I think that's for three reasons - I'm sure my fellow panelists will have others to add to these.

The first is that it returns the War of Independence to its full British transatlantic and imperial context by thinking of the commonalities on both sides of the Atlantic and indeed around the Atlantic that framed and shaped the course of the War of Independence;

secondly it liberates the War of Independence from a nationalist teleology that was imposed back upon those events particularly from the 19th century making it an event in the history of the United States even before the United States existed, but more importantly in this context, it restores the very deep divisions that characterise the war itself within North America but also again within the British Empire and in Britain itself, and also reminds us of the often terrible violence that took place during the war of independence something that later nationalist accounts tended to gloss over;

and thirdly and finally I think it's historically important to rethink it rethink the War of Independence as a civil war because that those are exactly the terms that contemporaries used to describe it, for example the very first Declaration from the Second Continental Congress in July 1775 the Declaration on taking up arms said that the American cause was not to declare independence but rather to save the Empire from the calamities of Civil War and very similarly the official British government response to the Declaration of Independence accused the Americans themselves of fomenting Civil War ..."

..........................

From 14:16 –

"... the overall way to think about this is again not in the terms of the nationalist narrative which effectively tells the story of the American Revolution as a crisis of disintegration - as it were proto Americans discovering their own identity attached themselves to a certain set of values which then they put into practice against the predatory invasions of Ministry, Parliament and the Crown - we should think of it in in fact in the exactly the opposite way, as a crisis of integration. By the 1760s and 1770s most of the white colonists in the 13 colonies and indeed the other British colonies on the western side of the Atlantic thought of themselves as more British in their mores in their attachment to common law in the way in which they organised property relations but also in the ways in which they were for example bound together by the fruits of a modernising consumer revolution ..."

..........................

From 48:00 –

“... this is also relevant to the ideological context for the colonies going all the way back to the attachment of Britons, the common attachment of Britons as Britons, to what they saw as their peculiar inheritance of civil liberty guaranteed by the Revolutionary settlement of 1688 to 1689 - so as well as expanding our geographical range to see the American crisis in a global context we also need to pull out the temporal context and take it all the way back to 1688-89 to see how debates about civil liberty, the definitions of those, how they're related to conceptions of consent, of representation of parliament ..."

..........................



Monday, November 03, 2025

The 1689 London Baptist Confession, and the aftermath of King James II's 1685 'Bloody Assizes'

Above: the 50 locations of 315 public executions during King James II's 'Bloody Assizes', August - December 1685.

................

This article, in the Baptist Quarterly, January 1930 edition, is worth a look. Baptists were one of the 'non-conformist' denominations in England who were persecuted under the 'absolute monarch' regimes of Charles II and then James II, from 1661-1688. G.M. Trevelyan, in his England Under the Stuarts (1904; online here), described these as 'The Reigns of Terror'.

State power was unleashed upon the civilian populations who believed that no King was head of the church. Persecuting 'Clarendon Code' laws targeted them. 2000 non-conformist ministers ejected in England alone. John James was executed. Benjamin Keach persecuted. John Bunyan imprisoned. Isaac Watts senior* imprisoned twice. Richard Baxter put on trial... men whose writings are revered in theological circles today, but whose sufferings are almost forgotten.

Some Baptists turned their farming implements into weapons and joined the Duke of Monmouth's Rebellion of summer 1685, forging their ploughshares into swords. The rebellion failed.

The lists of the 850 'rebels' who were sold as slaves, and of the 315 more who were publicly executed, still exist. The Baptist Quarterly article picks up on those sources –


These lists deserve close attention from the secretaries of the Somerset and Dorset Baptist churches, which contributed scores, if not hundreds, to the ranks of the insurgents.

The Lyme Regis church was foremost, and it is not surprising to see the pastor, Sampson Lark, with John Holloway, the tobacconist, amongst the earliest who paid forfeit.

Other Dorset names well known in Baptist circles are Bevis, Collier, Cox, Elliot, Sprake, Waldron. Colonel Abraham Holmes and Will Hewling were Baptist, but had landed with Monmouth.

Benjamin Hewling was convicted at Taunton; the story is well known how his grandfather, (William) Kiffin of London interceded but could only obtain that he should not be quartered, but buried whole...

The grave losses sustained by our churches in Somerset and Dorset, still affected them four years later, and so when the churches of all England were represented at London in 1689, the West did not give its usual lead, which it only recovered after ten years. Some real harm was done, the effects of which persisted for nearly a century.

We commend to some Baptist antiquary in the Taunton district, that he take the official lists in the Calendar of State Papers, and try to trace his spiritual ancestors who fought against James as their fathers against his father.

 


Above: a photo I took of Lyme Regis Baptist Church back in 2016. Local pastor, Sampson Larke, was one of twelve who were hanged, drawn and quartered on the beach on 12 September 1685; another of them was William Hewling referred to above. When visiting Lyme Regis earlier this year I went to the churchyard of St Michael the Archangel Parish Church, where William Hewling's remains had been buried. His gravestone had been taken away some time in the early 1900s - see previous post here. The significantly-named Monmouth Street is directly opposite the church.

...........................

In November 1688 King James II was of course overthrown by a European-wide alliance headed by William, Prince of Orange, who, in 1689, with his wife Queen Mary II jointly signed into law a new Bill of Rights for the people.

From 3rd - 11th "of the seventh month" of 1689 (back then the seventh month of the year was not July, but September) an assembly of 37 Baptist pastors gathered in London, and published the 1689 Baptist Confession. This dedicated website contains the full text, and also lists all of the local pastors who were signatories.

• Those who were from the ravaged south west - Samuel Buttall of Plymouth, William Phipps of Exeter, John Ball of Tiverton (where the local congregational pastor was beheaded, and his head then displayed on the market cross), James Hitt of Dalwood, Thomas Winnel of Taunton, Toby Willes of Bridgwater, Andrew Gifford of Bristol and James Webb of Devizes - must have brought horrific tales to the liberated capital. 

• Also among the 37 was William Kiffin, the pastor of Devonshire Square Baptist Church in London, whose nephews William and Benjamin Hewling had been publicly executed at Lyme Regis and Taunton respectively. Decades before, Kiffin had been one of the authors of the 1644 Baptist Confession of Faith. The 1823 edition of Remarkable passages in the life of William Kiffin is online here.

• James Hitt was the temporary pastor of the congregation at Dalwood near Axminster – the beautiful, secret, thatched meeting house still exists and is cared for by the National Trust.

...........................

* The hymnwriter Isaac Watts (1674-1748), perhaps reflecting on his Southampton childhood memory of the persecutions under Charles II and James II (men were hanged drawn and quartered at Wareham in 1685 - see previous post here), wrote these words:

“Must I be carried to the skies, On flowery beds of ease?
While others fought to win their prize, And sailed through bloody seas?”

Above: The 1689 Baptist Confession was reprinted in the USA, by Benjamin Franklin in 1743 and later reprinted by John Dunlap in 1773. They would of course collaborate in the publishing of the Declaration of Independence on 4th July 1776.


It's almost a century since that Baptist Quarterly article highlighted the need for further research, perhaps that still needs to be done.


Above: the locations of the 37 pastors named in the 1689 Baptist Confession

...........................

• Connected with all of this is the remarkable Daniel Defoe. This superb analysis of his most famous work Robinson Crusoe, by Tom Paulin in the London Review of Books in 2001, is a masterclass. As Paulin shows, the executed William and Benjamin Hewling had been schoolfriends of Defoe when they attended Cornwall-born Charles Morton's Dissenting Academy at Newington Green in London. Morton left England for America in 1686, where he became Vice-President of Harvard.


Above: tattoo of Joe Thorn's hand (online here).


Tuesday, October 21, 2025

Gideon Blackburn (1772-1838) - "The great Elijah of our day" / Cherokee chief Doublehead / John Gloucester


Gideon Blackburn was born in Augusta County, Virginia - on the cusp of the Revolution and three years before his community expressed their desire for liberty in their Augusta Resolves at Staunton. Augusta was the county that George Washington's famous (unconfirmed) "if defeated everywhere else" quote was based upon.

Gideon's grandfather William Blackburn was from Ballymena and was onboard one of the first big Ulster-Scots emigration waves, leaving in 1719 and settling at Yorktown. His son Robert Blackburn was among those to enter the Shenandoah Valley in the 1750s - he married Sarah Ritchie. Gideon was born in 1772.

The Tennessee Encyclopedia has this amazing biography of Gideon – pioneer settler of Tennessee, Presbyterian minister, educator, missionary, whiskey smuggler ...

"a staunch ally of the powerful acculturationist chief Doublehead, to whom he offered sanctuary shortly before Cherokee nationalists assassinated him in 1807"

... a friend of Andrew Jackson, purchaser and liberator of the Black slave John Gloucester, whom Gideon tutored and who later became the first African American Presbyterian minister in America. Gloucester was the first African American to enrol at Greeneville College / Tusculum University in Tennessee, which was co-founded by Ulsterman Samuel Doak.

• a detailed bio of Gideon Blackburn, written in 1934 by VM Queener for the East Tennessee Historical Society, is online here.

• An article in the Journal of Presbyterian History (Vol 5, Fall 1974) begins:

"Gideon Blackburn was a child of the southwestern frontier. Born in Augusta County, Va., on 27 August, 1772, to Scotch-Irish parents with little or no property, the boy was early orphaned and lived with his paternal grandfather until the latter's death when Gideon was about twelve years old. Thereafter he lived with an unmarried maternal uncle, Gideon Richie, a manual laborer who

like so many others of his class and age followed the current of migration toward the West. When the younger Gideon was about fifteen, he moved with this uncle to Washington County, Tennessee, then within the bounds of North Carolina. About three years later the two moved seventy miles further west, to Jefferson County, Tennessee".


(PS: in the trio of photos above I have used this image of Doublehead's brother, which has been used as the basis of recent depictions of Doublehead himself).

Thursday, October 16, 2025

Sydney George Fisher - "The True History of the American Revolution" (1902)

Ropey history is nothing new.

In 1898, Pennsylvania author Sydney George Fisher (1856-1927; Wikipedia here) incurred the ire of the Scotch-Irish Society. At the Ninth Annual Meeting and Banquet of the Pennsylvania Scotch-Irish Society (at the Hotel Bellevue in Philadelphia; publication online here) various remarks were made – and the Society's Second Vice President Judge John Stewart (bio here) offered a lengthy critique – about Fisher's portrayal of the Scotch-Irish in his 1896 book Pennsylvania, Colony and Commonwealth (online here). To the Society's credit, they also printed Fisher's rebuttal (page 107 here).

A few years later Fisher published his True History of the American Revolution, in 1902 (online here). The title is itself a bold claim, which encapsulates his frustrations and how the subsequent re-tellings of 1776 had warped and mutated away from the original sources. It's packed with brilliant material. He sets out his assertive stall right away in the first sentences of the preface:

"... The purpose of this history of the Revolution is to use the original authorities rather more frankly than has been the practice with our historians. They appear to have thought it advisable to omit from their narratives a great deal which, to me, seems essential to a true picture. I cannot feel satisfied with any description of the Revolution which treats the desire for independence as a sudden thought ..."


And his concise summary of the contemporary context in Britain and Ireland is a masterclass in simplicity, in capturing the Whig/Tory distinctions, explaining the issue as one of liberty rather than nationality –

"... It is important to remember the condition of parties in England and the phases of opinion among them during the Revolution. 

As time went on a large section of the Rockingham Whigs, and men like the Duke of Richmond and Charles Fox, were in favor of allowing the colonies to form, if they could, an independent nation, just as, in the year 1901, a section of the liberal party were in favor of allowing the Boer republics of South Africa to retain their independence.

The rest of the Whigs, represented by such men as Barré, Burke, and Lord Chatham, would not declare themselves for independence. They professed to favor retaining the American communities as colonies; but they would retain them by conciliation instead of by force and conquest. Their position was an impossible one, because conciliation without military force would necessarily result in independence. They professed to think that the colonies could be persuaded to make an agreement by which they would remain colonies. But such an agreement would be like a treaty between independent nations, and imply such power in the colonies that the next day they would construe it to mean independence.

The Tories could see no merit in the independence of any country except England. They believed that the colonies should remain completely subordinate dependencies, like the English colonies of the present day; and be allowed no more liberty or self-government than was for the advantage of the empire, and such as circumstances should from time to time indicate.

As to the method of reducing the colonies to obedience, the Tories were somewhat uncertain. At first most of them, led by such men as Lord North, Lord Hillsborough, and Lord Dartmouth, were in favor of a rather mild method of warfare, accompanied by continual offers of conciliation and compromise. They were led to this partly by considerations of expense and the heavy debt already incurred by the previous war, by the desire to take as much wind as possible out of the sails of the Whigs by adopting a semi-Whig policy, by the desire to avoid arousing such hatred and ill-will among the colonists as would render them difficult to govern in the future, and by the fear that the patriot party, if pressed too hard, would appeal to France or escape beyond the Allegheny Mountains and establish republican or rights of man communities which would be a perpetual menace and evil example to the seaboard colonies.

Exactly how much conciliation and how much severity the ministry wished to have in their policy is difficult to determine. Within two or three years they changed it and favored a quick, sharp, relentless war, with such complete destruction and devastation of the country as would collapse the patriot party, avoid all necessity of any sort of compromise and leave the colonies to be remodelled and governed in any way the ministry saw fit.

It is quite obvious that, besides getting aid from France, Spain, or Holland and their own personal powers, it was very important for the patriot party in the colonies to have the Whigs go into power, or come so near going into power that they would influence Tory policy. 

Many people believed that the whole question depended on the patriots holding out long enough to let the Whigs get into power, and that if the Whigs were successful for only a few months the whole difficulty would be settled. 

When, finally, peace was declared and the treaty acknowledging independence signed in 1783, it was done by a Whig ministry. Tories do not sign treaties granting independence ..."

 

He also included multiple references to the 1688 origins of 1776, such as:

"... but perhaps their greatest [Whig] triumph was in the revolution of 1688, when they dethroned the Stuart line, established religious liberty, destroyed the power of the crown to set aside acts of Parliament, and created representative government in England. For the most of their existence; however, they would have been able to live in America more consistently with their professed principles than in England.

On the present occasion, in the year 1775, after they had expended all of their eloquence and stated all of their ideas, and shown themselves in the eyes of the majority of Englishmen absolutely incompetent to settle the American question, except by giving the colonies independence, the Tory majority proceeded to its duty of preserving the integrity of the empire in the only way it could be preserved ..."

 

• In 1912 Fisher followed up with The Legendary and Myth-Making Process in Histories of the American Revolution (online here).

• Back in 1897 he had published The Evolution of the Constitution of the United States (online here), showing how many of the clauses had their origins in the reign of William III and Mary II

I hope that "USA 250" avoids myth-making and ropey history, and instead presents a narrative that is true to the 1776 era, unaffected and uninfected by our present-day prejudices on both sides of the Atlantic.


Tuesday, October 14, 2025

"The cause of liberty and the rights of mankind" – The Presbyterian Synod resumes its 'Pastoral Letter', 24 May 1783


Just after American Revolutionary war had begun, the Presbyterian Synod which covered all of the 13 Colonies issued its historic 'Pastoral Letter' to all of its member congregations, on 12 June 1775 (see previous post here). No more were issued until the war was over and independence had been secured; peace negotiations began in Paris in April 1782 (concluding with the formal Treaty of Paris of 3 September 1783).

A new 'Pastoral Letter' was issued from Philadelphia on 24 May 1783, with John M'Crery / McCrery / McCreary (1732-1800) the minister of White Clay Creek and also Head of Christiana Presbyterian Church, Newark, New Jersey, as its moderator (see the Presbytery of New Castle list here).

The letter is a retrospective on the times they had all lived through, and also expresses aspirations for the future of the newly independent United States. It's online here – the text is below.

...............

A Pastoral Letter from the Synod of New York and Philadelphia to the people under their charge, May 1783.

Very dear brethren,

You will easily remember, that in May 1775, the Synod thought proper to address a pastoral letter to the people under their inspection, on the state of public affairs.

At that interesting period, hostilities had just commenced between Great Britain and America, and a long and bloody conflict was to be expected. Now that conflict is over, and we have the best reason to suppose (the preliminaries being signed and ratified) that a happy and honourable peace will be speedily settled by a definitive treaty. We could not therefore longer delay addressing to you the following letter, which will contain our sentiments on this happy occasion, and our advice as to the duty incumbent upon all ranks in return for so great a mercy.

We cannot help congratulating you on the general and almost universal attachment of the Presbyterian body to the cause of liberty and the rights of mankind. This has been visible in their conduct, and has been confessed by the complaints and resentment of the common enemy. Such a circumstance ought not only to afford us satisfaction on the review, as bringing credit to the body in general, but to increase our gratitude to God for the happy issue of the war; had it been unsuccessful, we must have drunk deeply of the cup of suffering. Our burnt and wasted churches, and our plundered dwellings, in such places as fell under the power of our adversaries, are but an earnest of what we must have suffered had they finally prevailed.

The Synod therefore request you to render thanks to Almighty God for all his mercies spiritual and temporal, and in a particular manner for establishing the Independence of the United States of America. He is the Supreme Disposer of all events, and to him belongs the glory, the victory, and the majesty. We are persuaded you will easily recollect many circumstances in the course of the struggle, which point out his special and signal interposition in our favour. Our most remarkable successes have generally been when things had just before worn the most unfavourable aspect, as at Trenton and Saratoga at the beginning, in South Carolina and Virginia towards the end of the war. It pleased God to raise up for us a powerful ally in Europe, and when we consider the unwearied attempts of our enemies to raise dissension by every topic that could be supposed inflammatory and popular, the harmony that has prevailed not only between the allied powers, but the troops of different nations and languages acting together, ought to be ascribed to the gracious influence of Divine Providence. Without mentioning many other instances, we only further put you in mind of the choice and appointment of a commander in chief of the armies of the United States, who in this important and difficult charge has given universal satisfaction, who alike acceptable to the citizen and the soldier, to the state in which he was born, and to every other on the continent, whose character and influence, after so long service, are not only unimpaired but augmented. Of what consequence this has been to the cause of America, every one may judge, or if it needs any illustration, it receives it from the opposite situation of our enemies in this respect. On the whole, every pious person, on a review of the events of the war, will certainly be disposed to say, with the Psalmist, the Lord hath done great things for us, whereof we are glad.

Suffer us to put you in mind of the duty which you owe to God in return for this great national deliverance. You ought to testify your gratitude by living in his fear. This is the only way by which public prosperity can become a real mercy to you. It were to be wished, indeed, that in our contests about the most important interests of a temporal nature, we could still remember, not only that eternity is of greater moment than any thing that relates merely to the present life, but that all outward things, and even civil liberty itself, ought to be considered as subordinate and subservient to an everlasting happiness. It would not be an honour to us to be wholly unconcerned about the rights of ourselves and others, as men and as citizens, yet the great object of our duty, and, we hope, of our desires, is to watch for your souls, as those that must give an account to God. We therefore earnestly beseech every one who is nominally of our communion, not to be satisfied with a form of godliness, denying the power thereof. The substance of religion is the same to all denominations, neither is there any preference due to one before another, but in so far as it has superior advantages in leading men to the saving knowledge of the only living and true God, and Jesus Christ whom he hath sent, whom to know is life eternal.

There is no doubt that you look upon it as a happy circumstance in the late revolution, that the rights of conscience are unalienably secured, and even interwoven with the very constitutions of the several states. The duty which you owe to the community at large for this inestimable blessing, is to support civil authority, by being subject not only for wrath, but also for conscience sake, and by living quiet and peaceable lives in all godliness and honesty. It is a truth of much moment, and particularly to be remembered at this time, not only that the virtue of the people in general is of consequence to the stability of every civil society, but that it is of much greater moment to the stability of republics or free states, than those of a different kind. In monarchies, a sense of honour, the subordination of rank in society, and the vigour of despotic authority, supply in some measure the place of virtue, in producing public order; but in free states, where the power is ultimately lodged in the body of the people, if there is a general corruption of the mass, the government itself must speedily be dissolved.

You cannot but have observed, that the war has occasioned great irregularity and relaxation as to the observation of the Sabbath, and attendance on public ordinances. In some places congregations are broken up; in some places, for a considerable time, attendance was difficult, dangerous or impossible. The public service also, which made some things really necessary, was often made a pretence for ir regularity when no necessity existed. It is therefore your duty, now that peace and harmony have returned, to revive and restore the respect due to the Sabbath and the worship of God's sanctuary. The regular administration of Divine ordinances is a blessing that cannot be too highly valued or purchased at too great a price. We hope, therefore, that you will, in general, exert yourselves, and do every thing in your power that will serve to promote so noble a purpose. Be cheerful and liberal in assisting to educate pious youth for the ministry. Let vacant congregations be active and diligent to supply themselves with fixed pastors ; and let those which have fixed pastors strengthen their hands in their Master's work, not only by obedience in the Lord, but by making such provisions for their comfortable subsistence as that their duty may be practicable. We make this demand clearly and explicitly, because it is founded upon the plainest reason – upon the word of God – upon general or common utility, and your own interest, and make no doubt that wherever is true religion, it will be heard and complied with.

We look upon it as a very happy circumstance in the political revolution that has happened in America, that neither in its rise nor progress was it intermixed or directed by religious controversy. No denominations of Christians among us have any reason to fear oppression or restraint, or any power to oppress others. We therefore recommend charity, forbearance, and mutual service. Let the great and only strife be who shall love the Redeemer most, and who shall serve him with the greatest zeal. We recommend the strict exercise of discipline to the societies under our care. Let us not seek to increase our numbers by relaxation, but to justify the excellence of our principles by the inoffensive, exemplary and holy conversation of those who embrace them. The ultimate trial of religious truth is by its moral influence; therefore, as he is undoubtedly the best husbandman who raises the richest crops, so these are the best principles, which make the best men. This is the great rule laid down by our Saviour, by their fruits ye shall know them,

By order,

John McCrery, Moderator

...............

• McCrery was one of the early trustees of Newark College, which had developed from the 'free school' founded by Francis Alison which later became the Academy of Newark. 

• Many revolutionary figures were buried in the Head of Christiana Church cemetery - online here.


Monday, October 13, 2025

Ken Burns is wrong - "The American Revolution", his new six part mega-series, needs to be a lot smarter than this interview


Is this recent interview with YouTuber Theo Von, documentary filmmaker Ken Burns says this:

"... the great ideas are the greatest ideas ever. I actually think the American Revolution is the most important event since the birth of Christ. 

I really, really firmly believe that because if you think about it, up until that moment, everybody was under an authoritarian rule. They were subjects. They were superstitious peasants. And we created citizens. And that's a big deal. 

When we say we hold these truths to be self-evident, there was nothing self-evident about what Jefferson was about to say, that all men are created equal. No one on earth had made that proposition that they're endowed by their creator with certain unalienable rights that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. Let's go. That is not stuff that the world had ever really heard. 

He had distilled a century of enlightenment thinking. He'd been goaded on by what was happening in in the breakdown of relationships with the British over stuff and what became a quarrel between Englishmen suddenly got broken out into natural rights ..."

This is so far wrong, and historically illiterate, as to be mind-boggling.

If this is some insight into the narrative that Ken Burns' forthcoming mega-series will present, it will be a massive disappointment. It might play well into Trump 2.0-era 'America First' patriotism and jingoism, but not even Thomas Jefferson himself believed what Burns is here attributing to Jefferson.

Professor Garry Wills' magnificent Inventing America: Jefferson's Declaration of Independence (published 1978, see previous post here) is THE core text of the past generation, and expressly, repeatedly, shows the origins of the concepts, statements and vocabulary that the Committee of Five drew upon, frequently referring to Francis Hutcheson, John Locke and the 1688 'Glorious' Revolution among a host of prior inspirations.

The key words than Burns uses here – "inalienable" is from Hutcheson / "all men", "evident", "liberty" and "happiness" are from the intro to William Prince of Orange's 1688 Declaration.

The massive danger of USA250 is that it will mutate the history to play into the narrowness of present-day nationalisms – certainly in America, and probably in Ireland too – rather than challenge, educate and inform.

Liberty was not invented in Philadelphia in 1776. As Samuel Rutherford treasonously wrote in rural Scotland in 1644 – "every man is born free".

 

Sunday, October 12, 2025

Demographics and the Declaration of Independence - William Warren Sweet's 'The Story of Religion in America' (1939)

A while ago, as part of a podcast style discussion I was taking part in, one of the viewers asked a question about the Catholic Irish during the American Revolution.

It's an excellent question – when I was in Boston nearly 2 years ago I saw the monument to Wexford-born Commodore John Barry of the US Navy (my photos below) on Boston Common. Tomorrow, 13 October, is the 150th anniversary of the founding of the US Navy, and Barry was given his first command on 7 December 1775, of the ship Lexington.

As a general source for the religious demographics of Revolution-era America, William Warren Sweet's 1939 book The Story of Religion in America is frequently cited.

On page 293 he says that "at the close of the Revolution the number of Catholics in the United States numbered some 24,000, the great majority being found in Maryland and Pennsylvania. There were 24 clergy...". Sweet also says that in 1784 a letter by John Carroll (later Archbishop John Carroll) specified "15,800 in Maryland, 1,500 in New York, 7,000 in Pennsylvania, and 200 in Virginia".

That's the total figure; a few sources estimate that around 10,000 of those were from Ireland. Compared with the circa 200,000 Scotch-Irish who were in the 13 Colonies at the time, that gives a ratio of about 20:1.







Tuesday, September 30, 2025

Andrew Cunningham McLaughlin on the American Revolution - 1776 as the reclaiming of what 1688 had aspired to be


"The reasoning of the colonists was wanting in some of the essentials of revolutionary thinking — that is to say, wanting in an attitude of rebellion toward established institutions, lacking an attitude of mind which would welcome an overturning and would sweep away the past and build new structures on its ruins. Colonial reasoning was both abstract and concrete. It was concrete and historical because it referred definitely to actual working institutions; it was in a measure abstract because it laid stress upon natural rights that were postulates of argument.

But, it must always be remembered, those rights, as the colonists viewed them, were embodied in British citizenship; they had been given a degree of actuality in British constitutional doctrine; they had been announced time and again by revered British thinkers and political leaders, and, in part at least, were woven into the history of the “glorious revolution” of 1688, which was as near to the colonists as the days of Lincoln are to the men and women of the fourth decade of the twentieth century.

It would be folly, of course, to deny that there was nothing in the spirit and history of English constitutionalism on which the colonists could base their demands."

- From the Pulitzer Prize winning A Constitutional History Of The United States by Andrew Cunningham McLaughlin (1935).

• Available on Archive.org here.


Monday, September 29, 2025

Friedrich Hayek, "The Constitution of Liberty" (1960) - once again, showing the 1688 origins of 1776


'... The [American Revolution] movement in the beginning was based entirely on the traditional conceptions of the liberties of Englishmen*. Edmund Burke and other English sympathizers were not the only ones who spoke of the colonists as “not only devoted to liberty, but to liberty according to English ideas, and on English principles”; the colonists themselves had long held this view.

They felt that they were upholding the principles of the Whig revolution of 1688; and as “Whig statesmen toast[ed] General Washington, rejoiced that America had resisted, and insist[ed] on the acknowledgment of independence,” so the colonists toasted William Pitt and the Whig statesmen who supported them...'

- The Constitution of Liberty is online here

* 'Englishmen' was of course a term denoting the legal status of all people living in crown territories, not just those who were from England. Again, in our era, we tend to confuse nationality with liberty.







Thursday, September 25, 2025

Charleston, South Carolina, 1776 - comparing King George III with King James II


Charleston in South Carolina was the scene of a number of armed encounters in 1775 and 1776, between local patriot American 'Britons', versus the regiments of King George III (which included 12,000 German 'hessian' soldiers who had been hired in as reinforcements.

In May of 1776, the Charleston newspaper The South Carolina and American General Gazette published a huge three page article listing all of the similarities between King George III and King James II, the tyrant king who was overthrown in the Glorious Revolution of 1688. 

"If I turn my thoughts to recollect in history, a change of government upon more cogent reasons, I say, I know of no change upon principles so providing – compelling – justifiable. And in these respects, even the famous Revolution in England in the year 1688 ... we need no better authority than that famous precedent; and I will therefore compare the causes of, and the law upon, the two events..."

George III shipped 12,000 German soldiers to America to reinforce his army - this can be compared with James II shipping 6000 French soldiers to Ireland in 1689 to reinforce his. 


 

Tuesday, September 23, 2025

1776: Power versus the People

 In Edmund Burke's Annual Register, Volume 19 (1776) he makes this statement –

In Ireland, though those in office, and the principal nobility and gentry declared against America, by far the majority of the protestant inhabitants there, who are strenuous and declared whigs, strongly leaned to the cause of the colonies.

Online here 




Friday, September 19, 2025

Boston 1750 - "A Discourse concerning Unlimited Submission and Non-Resistance to the Higher Powers"

In mid 1700s America, the Ulster-Scots were not the only emigrant community to see history repeating itself through echoes of their ancestral past - of opposing a tyrant king, and connecting that experience with the 1688 Glorious Revolution.

Rev. Jonathan Mayhew's sermon A Discourse concerning Unlimited Submission and Non-Resistance to the Higher Powers, preached at the West Congregational Church in Boston in 1750, was said to have been "the most famous sermon preached in pre-Revolutionary America" (see ERR Green, Essays in Scotch-Irish History, p 44).

"... king Charles sat himself up above all these, as much as he did above the written laws of the realm ; and made mere humour and caprice, which are no rule at all, the only rule and measure of his administration. And now, is it not perfectly ridiculous to call resistance to such a tyrant, by the name of rebellion? the grand rebellion? 
Even that parliament, which brought king Charles II to the throne, and which run loyally mad, severely reproved one of their own members for condemning the proceedings of that parliament which first took up arms against the former king. 
And upon the same principles that the proceedings of this parliament may be censured as wicked and rebellious, the proceedings of those who, since, opposed king James II, and brought the prince of Orange to the throne, may be censured as wicked and rebellious also. The cases are parallel. But whatever some men may think, it is to be hoped that, for their own sakes, they will not dare to speak against the REVOLUTION, upon the justice and legality of which depends (in part) his present MAJESTY’s right to the throne..."  

• Full text is online here.

Virginia Gazette, 8 March 1776 - "Always for Liberty and the Public Good" - yet again, 1688 as the template for another revolution


"... The present ministry, notorious as they have rendered themselves for their attachment to those arbitrary principles in government in opposition to which our glorious ancestors fought, bled, and died, and by whose spirit and wisdom the liberty we enjoy has been rescued from former British tyrants...

A Congress was therefore appointed, consisting of delegates from the representatives of the people in every colony, that, by a union of their councils and strength, the common safety might be effectually obtained.

Those who deny this proceeding to be legal do plainly deny the legality of the [1688] Revolution, and that title by which the king of England now holds his crown; for when the people of England were abused by similar exertions of despotick power, they assembled by their representatives in 1688, not in Parliament, but in Convention (or Congress if you will) and determined to banish the tyrant STUART from the throne, and place thereon our glorious deliverer king WILLIAM, in succession to whom the present king now sways the sceptre of that country.

Thus you see, my countrymen, the appointment of a Congress is founded in reason, self-preservation, and the practice of England; but the present Tory ministry, and their secret directors, object to this proceeding, not only because it is agreeable to the purest principles of liberty, and the [1688] Revolution, both which they detest, but because the Congress, by their wise, spirited councils, and conduct, have effectually baffled the cabinet scheme for enslaving America..."

Wednesday, September 17, 2025

Speaking truth to power - The Virginia Gazette, 24 February 1776


"His Majesty knows that ... infringing the original rights and liberties of the people in any part of the British dominions, it is the exertion of such power - not the resistance to it - which constitutes rebellion. If this be not the case, the Glorious Revolution was above all rebellions the most atrocious".

- The Virginia Gazette, Williamsburg, 24 February 1776.

The cartoon below, entitled "The Political Cartoon for the Year 1775" (see Library of Congress website here) shows King George III and the Lord Chief Justice boasting of their nationality - whilst at the same time, led by horses labelled Obstinacy and Pride, trampling the Magna Carta and the Constitution / 1689 Bill of Rights)




Tuesday, September 16, 2025

When "loyalty" is actually "passive obedience" - The Whigs and the Tories, by Paul de Rapin de Thoyras, (1717; reprinted Boston 1773)


Its full title was A dissertation on the rise, progress, views, strength, interests and characters, of the two parties of the Whigs and Tories - written by the Huguenot Paul De Rapin in 1717, as a means of explaining English liberties and the Glorious Revolution which had seen De Rapin flee from persecution in France, and come to England with William Prince of Orange. Unsurprisingly, it was reprinted in Boston in 1773 by Joseph Greenleaf. It's on Archive.org here. Once again, 1688 is proven to be the template for 1776. The liberties of 1688 are what the Colonists sought in the 1770s. 

In our era we live in a 'headspace' of simplistic duality of competing nationalities - so much so that it's hard to explain to anyone that there are other ways of thinking and understanding. Competitive international sport has probably skewered us - for the past few generations we have watched countries line up against each other in athletics, football, rugby, cricket - even musically with the Eurovision Song Contest.

But within nation-states there are also competing ideologies, competing ideas as to how the nation should be run. Had the more liberty-oriented Whigs been in charge of Britain for the years from 1770-1782, America's British liberties would have been assured, and so would never have opted for independence. The Whigs weren't perfect in their handling of the Colonies, but it was the government of the Tory Prime Minister, Lord Frederick North, which enforced London rule upon America between 1770 and 1782, and which banjaxed and mismanaged the whole era, and in doing so, "lost" America. (The Whigs were back in again in March 1782 when the Marquis of Rockingham was once again made PM, for his second term, the first having ended in 1766).

De Rapin explains this:

"... that two parties appeared in the kingdom, one for the king, and one for the parliament, with a sort of equality ... The king's adherents at first had the name of cavaliers, which was afterwards changed into that of tories, and those of the parliament, then called roundheads, have received the name of whigs..."

and also

"... This parlicular branch of tories is considerable, in that, when they are in the ministry, they engage the church-tories strenuously to maintain the doctrine of passive-obedience, which goes a great way towards gaining the people to their party. They insinuate to the episcopal ministers, that they have only in view the ruin of the presbyterians, and under that pretence cause them to preach a doctrine, the consequence of which extends to all the subjects. This was experienced in the reigns of Charles II, of James II, and of queen Ann...

When the presbyterians were persecuted in Charles II's reign, passive-obedience was every where talked of. But it was still much worse under James II..." 

 

You will notice that De Rapin excludes William III from that chronology of monarchs!

...............

In the 1770s, King George III and Lord North refused to allow the American colonists their full British liberties as had been enshrined in each of the colonial Charters and also in the 1689 Bill of Rights. 

The colonists didn't - in simplistic, tabloid-headline, primary-school-level, nationalistic terms (terms that we are likely to hear a lot of over the next year) - "kick Britain out of America". Rather, the colonists rejected Tory rule from London and declared independence in order to secure those same British liberties.

"Loyalty" - in both the 1680s and the 1770s - would have been "passive obedience". But passive obedience under the guise of "loyalty" is the action of a docile population buckling to Stuart-esque tyrannical rule.

There is a time for resistance, in pursuit of liberty. It happened in 1688 - and it happened again in 1776.






Monday, September 15, 2025

John Allen aka "British Bostonian" - the Baptist pastor and his "Oration Upon the Beauties of Liberty" (1773)


This guy has come up in recent reading – John Allen was English, not Ulster-Scots - and arrived in Boston in 1772. His writing about constitutional liberties is superb; John Adams acknowledged that "large circles of the common people" had read Allen's words. They are:

• The American Alarm, Or The Bostonian Plea, For the Rights, and Liberties, of the People. Humbly Addressed to the King and Council; and to the Constitutional Sons of Liberty, in America. Text is online here.

"...For the right of the King to reign upon the throne of Great Britain, lies in his being (by the happy [Glorious] revolution principles) settled by the choice of the people as their elect King, or guardian of their rights. BUT when these walls (which are the walls of salvation to the people) are broken down, either Kingly, or Parliamentary power, then the King right to reign, and the obligations of the people to the King, or ministry, may justly cease. For when the rights of the people are violated, their affections not only become alienated, but their oath of allegiance to the King himself becomes void...

Let your own laws, your rights, your children's rights, and birthrights, inspire you with life, soul, and sentiment to let the King of England the British Parliament, or ministry know, nay, your own governor, and judges know your power, and importance as a people; that you will not lose your rights; that you will not be oppressed or imposed upon by Lord BUTE's despotic dictation in the Cabinet, or by any of the spirit or blood of the Stuart's family, which flows through the veins of the British ministry, that you will sooner lose your lives than your liberties...

Is it any breach of charity to think that Lord Bute intends hereby the overthrow both of King and State; to bring on a revolution, and to place another whom he more rearly allied to upon the Throne, (for GOD knows his last errand abroad); but however this may be at present a secret, yet if he does not aim at the dethroning the King, yet such proceedings will end in the destruction of the liberties of the people; and the one will certainly bring on the other. He thinks they have too much liberty, and therefore has long aimed to infringe their liberty, persuading the King, that he has a divine right to be despotic; and that the people ought to submit to his will and pleasure as his subjects..."



(image above from this website)


In The American Alarm Allen quoted from Dr Joseph Warren's Boston Massacre Oration of March 1772 (full text online here). In it Warren had said:

"... After various struggles, which, during the tyrannic reigns of the House of Stuart, were constantly kept up between right and wrong, between liberty and slavery, the connection between Great Britain and this colony, was settled in the reign of King William and Queen Mary, by a compact, the conditions of which were expressed in a charter; by which all the liberties and immunities of British subjects, were confined to this province, as fully and as absolutely as they possibly could be by any human instrument which can be devised. And it is undeniably true, that the greatest and most important right of a British subject is, that he shall be governed by no laws but those to which he either in person or by his representative hath given his consent: and this I will venture to assert is the grand basis of British freedom; it is interwoven with the constitution; and whenever this is lost, the constitution must be destroyed..."

.................

• An Oration, Upon the Beauties of Liberty, or the Essential Rights of the Americans, Delivered a the Second Baptist Church in Boston. Upon the last annual Thanksgiving, December 1772. Text is online here.

"... But God forbid that I should be thought to aim at rousing the Americans to arms, without their rights, liberties and oppression call for it. For they are unwilling to beat to Arms, they are loyal subjects; they love their King; they love their Mother-Country; they call it their HOME; and wish nothing more than the prosperity of Britain, and the glory of their King: But they will not give up their rights; they will not be slaves to any power upon Earth." 



.................

• Before he emigrated to America, in 1770 Allen had already published a pamphlet entitled The Spirit of Liberty; or, Junius's loyal address: being a key to the English cabinet; or, An humble dissertation upon the rights and liberties of the ancient Britons, in London, under the pseudonym Junius Jun. a Briton born. It is online here.



.................

• Article about Allen is on the New England Historical Society website here 

• Short biography of John Allen is on Jstor.org here - 'New England's Tom Paine: John Allen and the Spirit of Liberty', in The William and Mary Quarterly, Vol 21, No 4 (October 1964).


Thursday, September 11, 2025

After Independence - Edmund Burke: Speech in support of Lord John Cavendish’s motion for the revisal of all the laws aggrieving the Americans, 6 November 1776

(This text might be useful for someone out there. It's blistering stuff, Dublin-born Edmund Burke was Secretary to the previous Prime Minister, the Whig leader the Marquess of Rockingham - and after America had been 'lost' by political incompetence, after the horse had bolted, Rockingham had a brief second term as PM. Three counties in revolution-era America were given the name Rockingham County, due to the respect the colonists had for him. More about that to follow... )


6 November 1776

Rejoiced I am, Sir, that the learned gentleman has regained, if not his talent, at least his voice; that as he would not, or could not, reply the other night to my hon. friend, charmed as he must have been with the powerful reasoning of that eloquent speech, he had the grace to be silent. On that memorable occasion he lay, like Milton’s devil, prostrate “on the oblivious pool,” confounded and astounded, though called upon by the whole Satanic host. He lay prostrate, dumbfounded, and unable to utter a single syllable, and suffered the goads of the two noble lords to prick him till he scarcely betrayed a single sign of animal or mental sensibility. Why, Sir, would he not be silent now — instead of attempting to answer what in truth was unanswerable?

But the learned gentleman has now called to his assistance the bayonets of 12,000 Hessians; and as he thinks it absurd to reason at present with the Americans, he tells us that by the healing, soothing, merciful measures of foreign swords, at the breasts of those unhappy people, their understandings would be enlightened and they would be enabled to comprehend the subtleties of his logic. It was well said, on another occasion, that your speech demands an army! — and I may say, that the learned gentleman demands blood. Reasoning he says is vain: the sword must convince America and clear up their clouded apprehensions. The learned gentleman’s abilities surely desert him if he is obliged to call such a coarse argument as an army to his assistance; not that I mean anything reflecting on his parts. I always esteem, and sometimes dread, his talents.

But has he told you why commissioners were not sent sooner to America? Has he explained that essential point? Not a jot. Why, after the Act passed for them, were they delayed full seven months and not permitted to sail till May; and why was the commission appointing them delayed till the 6th of that month? Answer this. The blood and devastation that followed was owing to this delay; upon your conscience it ought to lay a heavy load. If the measure was right and necessary in order for conciliation, as the King declared in his speech at the opening of that session, why was it not executed at a time in which it could be effectual instead of being purposely deferred to one when it could not possibly answer any end but that of adding hypocrisy to treachery and insult and mockery to cruelty and oppression? By this delay you drove them into the declaration of independency, not as a matter of choice, but necessity. And now [that] they have declared it, you bring it as an argument to prove that there can be no other reasoning used with them but the sword. What is this but declaring that you were originally determined not to prevent but to punish rebellion, not to use conciliation but an army, not to convince but to destroy? Such were the effects of those seven months cruelly lost, to which every mischief that has happened since must be attributed.

But still the learned gentleman persists, that nothing but the commissioners can give peace to America — [that] it is beyond the power of this House. What was the result of the conference with the delegates from the Congress? Why, we are told that they met in order to be convinced that taxation is no grievance — “no tyranny” used to be the phrase; but that is out of fashion now. Then, Sir, what an insult to all America was it to send as commissioners none but the commanders of the fleet and army to negotiate peace! Did it not shew how much you were determined that the only arguments you meant to use were your broadswords and broadsides. Let me assert, Sir, that the doctrines to be laid down in America would not have been too trivial an occasion, even for the reasoning abilities of the learned gentleman himself. But, Sir, you may think to carry these doctrines into execution — and be mistaken too; the battle is not yet fought. But if it was fought and the wreath of victory adorned your brow, still is not that continent conquered.

Witness the behaviour of one miserable woman who, with her single arm, did that which an army of a hundred thousand men could not do — arrested your progress in the moment of your success. This miserable being was found in a cellar, with her visage besmeared and smutted over, with every mark of rage, despair, resolution, and the most exalted heroism, buried in combustibles, in order to fire New York and perish in its ashes. She was brought forth and, knowing that she would be condemned to die, upon being asked her purpose, said, “to fire the city!’’ and was determined to omit no opportunity of doing what her country called for. Her train was laid and fired; and it is worthy of your attention how Providence was pleased to make use of those humble means to serve the American cause, when open force was used in vain.

In order to bring things to this unhappy situation, did not you pave the way, by a succession of acts of tyranny? For this you shut up their ports, cut off their fishery, annihilated their charter, and governed them by an army. Sir, the recollection of these things, being the evident causes of what we have seen, is more than what ought to be endured. This it is that has burnt the noble city of New York, that has planted the bayonet in the bosoms of my principals — in the bosom of the city where alone your wretched government once boasted the only friends she could number in America. If this was not the only succession of events you determined, and therefore looked for, why was America left without any power in it, to give security to the persons and property of those who were and wished to be loyal — this was essential to government. You did not, and might therefore be well said to have abdicated the government.

Gods!  Sir, shall we be told that you cannot analyze grievances? — that you can have no communication with rebels because they have declared for independency? — Shall you be told this when the tyrant Philip did it after the same circumstance in the Netherlands. By edict he allowed their ships to enter their ports and suffered them to depart in peace; he treated with them; made them propositions; and positively declared that he would redress all their grievances. And James II, when he was sailing from France at the head of a formidable force, assisted like you by foreign troops, and having a great party in the kingdom, still offered specific terms — while his exceptions of pardon were few, amongst the rest my hon. friend’s ancestor, Sir Stephen Fox. But you will offer none. You simply tell them to lay down their arms and then you will do just as you please. Could the most cruel conqueror say less? Had you conquered the devil himself in hell, could you be less liberal? No! Sir, you would offer no terms. You meant to drive them to the declaration of independency; and even after it was issued, ought by your offers to have reversed the effect. You would not receive the remonstrance which I brought you from New York because it denied your rights to certain powers; yet the late king of France received the remonstrances from his parliaments that expressly denied his right to the powers he was in the constant exercise of, answered them, and even redressed some of the grievances which those very remonstrances complained of, though he refused to grant what he thought more peculiarly entrenched upon his own authority.

In this situation, Sir, shocking to say, are we called upon by another proclamation to go to the altar of the Almighty, with war and vengeance in our hearts, instead of the peace of our blessed Saviour. He said, “My peace I give you.” But we are, on this fast, to have war only in our hearts and mouths, war against our brethren. Till our churches are purified from this abominable service, I shall consider them, not as the temples of the Almighty, but the synagogues of Satan.

An act not more infamous, respecting its political purposes, than blasphemous and profane as a pretended act of national devotion, when the people are called upon, in the most solemn and awful manner, to repair to church, to partake of a sacrament, and, at the foot of the altar, to commit sacrilege, to perjure themselves publicly by charging their American brethren with the horrid crime of rebellion, with propagating “specious falsehoods,” when either the charge must be notoriously false, or those who make it, not knowing it to be true, call Almighty God to witness — not a specious but — a most audacious and blasphemous falsehood.

(The House groaned at this point of the speech, and some called out, “Order,” “Order.”) He said he rejoiced to hear such an involuntary burst of approbation of his remarks. He then repeated them, and, after urging the expediency of our ending the dispute with America, gave his hearty assent to Lord John’s motion.







Monday, September 08, 2025

Francis Alison - by John Adams and Benjamin Franklin

I'm throwing these references on here in case of interest to anyone. Someone needs to write a biography of Donegal-born Francis Alison, his influence on the American Revolution and the formation of the United States is remarkable...

……………………………………………..

JOHN ADAMS
Letters to his wife Abigail Adams

• 9 October, 1774

… This day I went to Dr. Allison's meeting in the forenoon, and heard the Dr.; a good discourse upon the Lord's supper. This is a Presbyterian meeting. I confess I am not fond of the Presbyterian meetings in this town. I had rather go to Church. We have better sermons, better prayers, better speakers, softer, sweeter music, and genteeler company. And I must confess that the Episcopal church is quite as agreeable to my taste as the Presbyterian. They are both slaves to the domination of the priesthood. I like the Congregational way best, next to that the Independent...

• Baltimore, 2 February, 1777

...I have been to meeting and heard my old acquaintance, Mr. Allison, a worthy clergyman of this town, whom I have often seen in Philadelphia. This day has been observed in this place with exemplary decency and solemnity, in consequence of an appointment of the government, in observance of a recommendation of Congress, as a day of fasting. I went to the Presbyterian meeting, and heard Mr. Allison deliver a most pathetic and animating as well as pious, patriotic, and elegant discourse. I have seldom been better pleased or more affected with a sermon... 

……………………………………………..

BENJAMIN FRANKLIN
Letter to Joshua Babcock, Philadelphia

• 1st September 1755.

Dear Sir, 

I beg leave to introduce to you the Revd. Mr. Allison, Rector of our Academy; a Person of great Ingenuity & Learning, a catholic Divine, &  what is more, an Honest Man; For as Pope says 

"A Wit's a Feather, & a Chief's a Rod;
An honest Man's the noblest Work of God." 

By Entertaining then this Gent, with your accustomed Hospitality & Benevolence, you will Entertain one of the Nobility. I mean one of God's Nobility; for as to the King's, there are many of them not worthy your Notice. 

Do me the Favour to make my Compliments acceptable to your good Lady, Sisters & Children in whose most agreeable Company I passed those chearful Winter Evenings, which I remember with high Pleasure. I am, with the greatest Esteem & Respect, 

Dr. Sir,
Your most obedt.
& most humble Servt.,
B. Franklin. 

……………………………………………..

EZRA STILES, PRESIDENT OF YALE

• 1757-1769

Correspondence from Allison (1757-1769) online here. 

……………………………………………..

PATRICK ALLISON (1740-1802)

Patrick's father, William Allison, and his mother, Catherine, were both from Ireland. He was born in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, and graduated from the University of Pennsylvania in 1760. In autumn 1763 he became the founder minister of the Church of the Presbyterians of Baltimore, a position he held for 39 years until his death in 1802. He had been approved for his position there by Francis Alison, but despite the similarity of surname it is not known if they were related. Patrick Allison became chaplain to General George Washington and the Continental Congress.

"Dr. Allison was active in civic affairs for all his career, acted often as Chaplain of the Continental Congress when it met in Baltimore, was one of the leaders in the formation of the Presbytery of Baltimore and of the General Assembly of our denomination"

..................

"These Scotch-Irish who played so important a part in the development and prosperity of the middle and western part of our country for some time prior to and after the Revolution were the descendants of those colonists from Scotland whom James I had settled in the early part of the seventeenth century in the six counties of Donegal, Derry, Tyrone, Fermanagh, Cavan and Armaugh in the province of Ulster in Ireland where some two million acres of land had lately escheated to the English crown.

These ScotchIrish who were mostly Presbyterians in faith had become quite numerous when the intolerance and persecution to which they were subjected after the death of King William III induced a number of them to emigrate to America. About 1719 the leases made shortly after the Revolution of 1688 and generally running for a term of thirty-one years, under which a large proportion of the Scotch-Irish tenants in Ulster held their farms, began to expire and they found themselves unable to renew them except at much higher rents.

The result was a large emigration of ScotchIrish to America from whence their former neighbors already settled there, had been writing back to them glowing accounts of their newly found homes in the Western World."

- from A Brief History of the First Presbyterian Church of Baltimore (1913)