Tuesday, February 04, 2025

Dr Guy Chet & Professor Bob Allison - "The Colonists' American Revolution; Preserving English Liberty, 1607-1783"

Here's a useful discussion, between Dr Guy Chet (author of the 2019 book The Colonists' American Revolution; Preserving English Liberty, 1607-1783; publisher page here), in conversation with Professor Bob Allison - about the American Revolution as a British rebellion for liberty. I met Professor Allison when visiting Boston in December 2023 for the 'Tea Party 250' commemorations. 

One of the challenges in telling the American Revolution story to a present-day audience is that we have all grown up with competing nations or competing nationalities as our only paradigm. Movies and war comics and the current affairs media have reduced our capacity to think, because they present everything as a contest between "two teams". And so the American Revolution has often been retro-fitted with these kinds of simplistic, easy-sell, nationalisms.

So, we need to work pretty hard to try to forget about ingrained nationalisms, of conflicts between nations, and think instead about liberty within the nation, or liberty which is worth more than the nation.

Not Americans v British, or Patriots v Loyalists, but rather Liberty v Tyranny. People on each side of the Atlantic were on each side of the cause.




Saturday, February 01, 2025

The dying embers of the Glorious Revolution – "Cato's Letters or Essays on Liberty, Civil and Religious", 1720s England


An American on Twitter recommended that I look at Cato's Letters - I'd heard of them, but had never taken the time to dig. Even though they were written in 1720s England (Wikipedia here) by John Trenchard and Thomas Gordon, they were a regular reference in 1770s America for the British 'colonists' who were preparing for a new Revolution. 

This was the era when Ulster-Scots emigration to America began at full speed, starting in 1718 and surging throughout the century to around 200,000 people. Cato's Letters are a fascinating new insight into the era, and of how liberty-oriented communities in 1720s Britain regarded the corrosive corruption of their own ruling classes.

"How did they behave towards King William, whom they themselves invited over? As soon as he gave liberty of conscience to Protestant dissenters; let them see that he would not be a blind tool to a priestly faction, but would equally protect all his subjects who were faithful to him; had set himself at the head of the Protestant interest, and every year hazarded his person in dangerous battles and sieges for the liberty of England and of Europe, against the most dreadful scourge and oppressor of mankind that ever plagued the earth"


Presumably that "scourge and oppressor" was the genocidal Louis XIV of France. The following extract describes how the Church of England establishment had first benefited from the achievements of 1688, but later, out of self-interest, eroded those achievements away –

"It is certain that there was almost every where a general detestation of popery, and popish principles, and a noble spirit for liberty, at or just before the Revolution; and the clergy seemed then as zealous as the foremost.

But when the corrupt part of them found themselves freed from the dangers which they complained of, and could not find their separate and sole advantage in the Revolution, they have been continually attacking and undermining it; and since they saw that it was impossible to persuade those who were witnesses and sufferers under the oppressions of the former governments, wantonly, and with their eyes open, to throw away their deliverance, they went a surer and more artful way to work, though more tedious and dilatory; and therefore have, by insensible degrees, corrupted all the youth whose education has been trusted to them, and who could be corrupted; so that at the end of near forty years, the Revolution is worse established than when it began.

New generations are risen up, which knew nothing of the sufferings of their fathers, and are taught to believe there were never any such."

The Cato Institute (online here) says this of the letters: "These essays popularised (John) Locke's ideas and were profoundly influential in both England and America. They are the inspiration for the Cato Institute. Published anonymously in the London Journal from 1720 to 1723, the 144 letters provide a compelling theoretical basis for freedom of conscience and freedom of speech. Virtually half the private libraries in the American colonies contained bound volumes of Cato’s Letters."

Cato's Letters are another treasure trove in understanding the era between the two Revolutions of 1688 and 1776, and how they connect to each other. The Letters are online at Libertyfund.org, as text-searchable PDFs via the links below (click on the download button, and then the 'eBook PDF' button)

Volume 1 (1720-21)
Volume 2 (1721-22)
Volume 3 (1722)
Volume 4 (1722-23)








Sunday, January 05, 2025

"Captain Kidd" (1945) and King William III

Yet another early Hollywood pirate movie, incorporating King William III. Wikipedia here.

Thursday, January 02, 2025

Celebrating the "Relief" of Londonderry, in Taunton in Somerset

In Joshua Toulmin's 1791 The History of Taunton in the County of Somerset, this account of Colonel Percy Kirke includes his breathtaking bloodlust inflicted upon the people of Taunton during the Bloody Assizes of Autumn 1685, yet also of them toasting him following his role in the Relief of Londonderry:

... the people of Taunton, in commemoration of his relieving Londonderry, when besieged by James II in 1689, devoted an evening to the drinking of his health in public, the expenses of which may be now seen in an old church-book... (page 543)

The events of 1688-90 are not restricted to Ireland and connect communities across our islands.