The three-part series Plandáil was produced in 2011 for BBC Northern Ireland, backed by the Irish Language Broadcast Fund, and was presented by Neil Martin. It is one of the best televisual accounts of the Scots' arrival in Ulster in the early 1600s that I have seen in recent years - and importantly, it explains the differences between what Hamilton & Montgomery did in east Ulster, in contrast to how events unfolded in west Ulster.
I have been invited to give a talk next Wednesday evening at the AGM of the Presbyterian Historical Society of Ireland, on the subject of Rev James Hamilton of Ballywalter (1600-1666), one of the first ministers to come across. One of the events that Hamilton is renowned for was a public debate with the Bishops in Belfast which was dramatised in Plandáil - you can see at around 29 minutes in to the clip below.
Hamilton's story is one which has interested me for many years, given that he was the first minister in the area where I live, and that - unlike his contemporaries Robert Blair, John Livingstone and Robert Cunningham, nothing has been written about him. The talk will be general, not drilling down into the obscure details, but I hope it will be interesting to the audience. I need to get the full version published and out of my system!
Sunday, March 09, 2014
Posted by Mark Thompson at Sunday, March 09, 2014
Monday, March 03, 2014
Above earth’s lamentation
I hear the sweet though far off hymn
That hails a new creation:
Through all the tumult and the strife
I hear the music ringing;
It finds an echo in my soul—
How can I keep from singing?
The Lord my Savior liveth;
What though the darkness gather round!
Songs in the night He giveth:
No storm can shake my inmost calm
While to that refuge clinging;
Since Christ is Lord of Heav’n and earth,
How can I keep from singing?
I see the blue above it;
And day by day this pathway smoothes
Since first I learned to love it:
The peace of Christ makes fresh my heart,
A fountain ever springing:
All things are mine since I am His—
This was first published in the 1860s by 'son of Ulster' Robert Wadsworth Lowry, who wrote the words and the tune. I am in touch with one of his descendants who hopes to visit Northern Ireland this summer to visit the townlands and villages of Killinchy and Crossgar where the Lowrys lived before emigrating. Over the years it has been recorded (and its lyrics altered to be more secular) by artists like Pete Seeger, Bruce Springsteen, Eva Cassidy and Enya.
Posted by Mark Thompson at Monday, March 03, 2014
Saturday, February 15, 2014
Thursday, February 13, 2014
Nearly 100 years ago, in March 1914, Rev James Barkley Woodburn (1872-1957), then minister of Castlerock Presbyterian Church in County Londonderry, wrote the introduction to his landmark book The Ulster Scot - His History and Religion.
It is an essential text in many ways. The Preface begins '... In Ireland there are three main divisions of the people ...', not the 'two tribes' of today. The 412 pages are a solid summary of our story right up to the Tenant Right movement of the late 1800s and early 1900s.
The book was published on 23 April 1914 (the day before the Ulster Volunteer Force guns were landed at Larne, Bangor and Donaghadee) and had glowing reviews in the newspapers of Ulster, Ireland, Scotland, England and Wales.
J.B.'s father was Rev Matthew Woodburn, minister of Ballywillan Presbyterian Church; his brother George would later become President of Magee College. In 1940 James Barkley Woodburn became Moderator of the General Assembly.
Posted by Mark Thompson at Thursday, February 13, 2014
Tuesday, February 11, 2014
"... the true and legitimate claim on the English crown, said the Scots, lay with the house of Wessex whose sole living representative was one Robert 1st of Scotland ..." (at 46.30)
- see GWS Barrow, page 315 here.
Posted by Mark Thompson at Tuesday, February 11, 2014
Saturday, February 08, 2014
The British ambitions of Robert and Edward Bruce, 1314-1318 - "he now dreamed of the crown of Britain"
|The Bruces' ultimate aim?|
In June 1314, Robert the Bruce defeated the Anglo-Norman King Edward II of England at the Battle of Bannockburn near Stirling. Throughout history it has been presented as the heroic victory which founded the Scottish nation, and confirmed Bruce as the undisputed King of Scotland. He had spent the previous seven years (ie when he returned to Scotland after his six month sojourn on Rathlin Island) attacking both the English occupying forces and rival Scottish lords, some of whom were pro-Edward and others who were just anti-Bruce.
The Scottish crown had been in dispute for many decades, but Robert the Bruce eventually emerged as the successful claimant, following years of manoeuvering by his father and grandfather. But ending up as rulers of Scotland was not necessarily the endgame of the Bruces' plans. They may have had a far bigger goal in mind. As far back as 1286 they had struck treaties and deals with leading figures across the North Channel - pointing the way to an Ulster-Scottish objective at the very least.
Robert the Bruce is said to have been married at Writtle in Essex (not born as many erroneosuly claim), to Elizabeth de Burgh, the daughter of the Earl of Ulster. Bruce had the title of 'Lord of Hartness' referring to an estate near Hartlepool which Edward II would confiscate from him around 1306. The Bruces knew England, especially the northern parts.
It was a year after Bannockburn, in May 1315, that Robert's only surviving brother Edward was authorised to take the 6000-strong Bannockburn army to Ulster, with the aim of forging an alliance with the powerful O'Neills (who some scholars say were blood relatives of the Bruces) and other lesser Gaelic clans to replicate what had happened in Scotland - to drive out the Anglo-Normans. Edward was crowned King of Ireland by his Irish supporters, probably in Carrickfergus at early June 1315 (although some other traditions say it was Dundalk in May 1316 - a pub there, Michael McCourt's, was once called King Bruce's Tavern and is on the reputed location of Sir Roger Mortimer's former castle. It still has a painted sign over the doorway and in the windows commemorating this tradition). The initial phase of the campaign was brutally successful with victory after victory in Ulster, Louth and Meath.
A pivotal victory for Edward Bruce at Kells in County Meath in November 1315, against the forces of Sir Roger Mortimer, opened up the possibility of a new front. Mortimer's uncle and namesake was an Anglo-Norman overlord in north west Wales. Sir Gruffydd Llwyd, leader of the Welsh, was bent upon rebellion and he invited Edward Bruce to come to Wales. The letters they exchanged still exist.
Further north in Great Britain, Robert was unsatisfied to have taken Scotland and he had spent the year pushing south with attacks into northern England, to Yorkshire (where previous generations of Bruces had been granted lands, and founded at least one priory, at Gisborough) and the Furness district of Lancashire, seizing iron ore which was brought back to Scotland. His army launched a seaborne attack on Hartlepool in 1315, torching the town.
But what of the Welsh invitation? Flushed with his successes in Ireland, Edward Bruce's reply informed the Welsh that he would come and help them... as long as they made him their new leader. They declined.
'… It was probably at this time of peaceful occupation of Ulster by the Scots, that Sir Gruffydh Llwyd, who was in rebellion again Edward II., wrote to Edward Bruce to invite him into Wales, that by the union of the Albanian Scots with the Britons, the Saxons might be driven out, the times of Brutus restored, and the whole of Britain divided between the Britons and the Scots. Edward Bruce, notwithstanding his Norman blood, agreed to the proposal on condition that he was to have such command and such lordship over the Welsh, ‘prout alius hactenus princeps vester liberius habere consuevit.’ These were bright visions for the Earl of Carrick's younger son, the proud and overbearing Edward Bruce; he had been crowned King of Ireland, he had a near prospect of the crown of Scotland, and he now dreamed of the crown of Britain …’
- Annales Hiberniae by James Grace of Kilkenny (c. 1537).
‘… The prospects of Edward Bruce were at this time at highwater mark; he was heir-presumptive to the throne of Scotland had in all probability already been crowned king of Ireland, and now received a communication from Gruffydh Llwyd, who was leading a rebellion in Wales, offering to support him as ruler of that country if he would assist in freeing them from the English, and even holding out the prospect that they might together expel the Saxons and establish the ancient kingdom of Britain …’
- The invasion of Ireland by Edward Bruce by Caroline Colvin (1901)
As late as 1322, Robert the Bruce's army fought the English at the Battle of Old Byland in Yorkshire, and burned Preston in Lancashire and wasted much of the north of the county.
The Bruce story is bigger than Scotland, and bigger than nationalistic interpretations of history. 20th and 21st century issues are not the same as the 14th century. The classic themes of ambition, power and control mean that, had the Bruces had their way, they would have become rulers of all of the British Isles. It is a story which, in different ways, Scotland, Northern Ireland, the Republic of Ireland, Wales, England - and even the Isle of Man - all share.
But of course, the Bruces failed in their bigger plan. Edward Bruce was killed in October 1318 when he went into battle at Faughart near Dundalk before his reinforcements had arrived.
The Bruces had not ousted the Anglo-Normans, but had certainly broken their hold on east Ulster - and shortly afterwards a branch of the O'Neills moved eastwards from Tyrone to take hold of south Antrim and north Down. Led by 'Yellow Haired Hugh', Clann Aodha Buidhe, they became known as the Clandeboye O'Neills and held the territory for the next 300 years.
In 1603, Robert the Bruce's lineal successor, King James VI of Scotland, became King of England and Ireland as well, succeeding to do politically what the Bruces had failed to do militarily.
Postscript: It was another deal between two Ayrshiremen and the O'Neills which made a lasting impact upon Ulster, when in 1605 King James VI & I's old mates Hugh Montgomery and James Hamilton struck a deal with Con O'Neill, chief of the Clann Aodha Buidhe O'Neills. In May 1606 Hamilton & Montgomery began a flood of Scottish families into Ulster - some of whom, like the Boyds of Kilmarnock and the Adairs of Kinhilt, 300 years earlier had fought alongside the Bruce brothers at Bannockburn and were granted their family estates as a reward.
Posted by Mark Thompson at Saturday, February 08, 2014